More on Why Leaning-in is B.S.
Posted on April 8th, 2013 in Uncategorized | No Comments »
On her blog, Plan B Nation, lawyer and writer Amy Gutman talks about seeing Sheryl Sandberg at the Coolidge Corner Theater in Brookline last Thursday.
She raises two great points.
First is the mixed messages that Sandberg herself sends—and seems incapable of not sending.
First was The Dress, a form-fitting little black number, at first glance unremarkable in this era of Corporate Alpha Female 2.0, where sexuality is proudly featured rather than downplayed—unremarkable, that is, until she turned her back and disclosed a gold-toned zipper running from top to bottom. …For me, this took the outfit from Seen This Before, to WTF. It seemed to be demanding some sort of response, though I’ve yet to figure out just what.
I’ve noted this about Sandberg, too—that for someone talking about how women can be more professional and more successful, she sexes it up in a way that, I think, undermines her message. Why? Vanity, I’d guess—looking good matters more to her than consistency. Which is her choice, but it makes me distrust the messenger.
Second, and more important, is the argument that leaning-in is a fatuous concept that ultimately puts the onus of change on the individual, rather than on corporations that resist it, and codifies none of this change into law or policy.
Women with full-time jobs and outside lives have very limited bandwidth. Here’s my, admittedly pessimistic, prognostication: The conversation about leaning in will slowly but surely supplant talk about on-site child care, work/life balance, and other “family friendly” policies….
I can’t help but think that Lean In offers a feminism tailor-made for our New Economy—one where the primary beneficiaries are companies, not women. Through the magic of Lean In, women’s initiative costs – poof! – transform into corporate profits.
I think that’s exactly right. Leaning-in is a wonderful thing for companies, which is why so many of them have signed on to Sandberg’s womanifesto. It asks nothing of them except the encouragement of women who want to work harder. It’s as if Lean In was secretly ghostwritten by Frederick WInslow Taylor.
But for Sheryl Sandberg, it doesn’t matter. She’s accomplished her primary goal: Creating a high-profile platform to advance her own career. What a missed opportunity to do something serious.