More Plagiarism
Posted on August 10th, 2012 in Uncategorized | 10 Comments »
It’s gone viral!
This time the evildoer is my college classmate Fareed Zakaria, who, in a column he “wrote” for Time, plagiarized from Jill Lepore in the New Yorker.
The good news is, you’re plagiarizing from a reliable source. The bad news? Apparently a lot of people read the New Yorker.
Conservative media watchdog Newsbusters was the first to spot the similarities between a Zakaria piece on gun control and an article by Jill Lepore that appeared in the New Yorker in April.
Zakaria has quickly apologized:
“Media reporters have pointed out that paragraphs in my Time column this week bear close similarities to paragraphs in Jill Lepore’s essay in the April 22nd issue of The New Yorker. They are right. I made a terrible mistake. It is a serious lapse and one that is entirely my fault. I apologize unreservedly to her, to my editors at Time, and to my readers.”
This apology irritates me somewhat, because while it sounds pretty straight-up, it isn’t. Yes, there were “paragraphs” that were similar, but really, they were more than “similar”—they were almost exactly the same, with a few minor alterations that seemed added to establish that they were not exactly the same. A more candid apology would use the word “plagiarized,” I think.
Fareed is far too smart for this, which makes me think that the Time column was written for him by a ghostwriter. (Hence the “entirely my fault” language-trying to discourage the idea that he didn’t even “write” the damn thing.)
A digression that isn’t really a digression: Back when I was editing the now-infamous Stephen Glass, I once asked Steve how he could be so prolific—simultaneously writing for George, the New Republic, GQ and more. He told me that he had insomnia and got a lot of work done when he should have been sleeping. Great excuse! I totally bought it. Of course, it was all bullshit.
The lesson I took from that experience is that people who seem like they’re doing much more than most of us could do in the same amount of time…probably aren’t really doing it.
We all know, for example, certain Harvard professors who travel the world, sit on the boards of private companies, host television series, attend countless galas, summer in lovely places, teach once in a (long) while…and yet somehow manage to have their names on a long list of books they’ve written, co-written, edited, etc. Which means often that graduate students do a hefty chunk of their work, for which they get job recommendations and a hat tip in the acknowledgements.
So…back to Fareed. He’s got a national magazine column, a weekly TV show, travels around the world, commencement speeches, and probably lots of other stuff that I don’t know about. That doesn’t leave much time for thinking and writing. Anyway, writing a column is hard, unglamorous work. It’s not as fun as hopping a jet to Davos or schmoozing at the Aspen Institute or giving speeches for which you’re paid tens of thousands of dollars.
But…if you say you do it…you kinda have to do it. You can’t leverage all the gravitas you get from writing a column into more lucrative and less demanding pursuits and then not actually write the column. That’s…you know…cheating.
Update: I haven’t even posted yet and already there’s new news. Time has suspended Zakaria.
10 Responses
8/10/2024 4:51 pm
Jim Sleeper bears down on some of the same questions on the HuffPo.
8/10/2024 5:15 pm
So does he get to stay on as Yale Trustee?
8/10/2024 5:19 pm
And CNN has suspended him too: http://www.deadline.com/2012/08/cnn-suspends-fareed-zakaria-for-plagiarism/
Good for them.
8/10/2024 6:58 pm
Lots to think about here. “Media reporters have pointed out….” Nice third person lede. What is the implication? That you hadn’t noticed until they pointed it out? I have caught myself thinking some turn of phrase in my writing was dreadfully clever, only to realize in horror that it was imitative. But whole paragraphs? People don’t remember whole sequences of sentences and reproduce them by accident. And it does look like they have been altered to disguise that they were copied.
So let’s assume that FZ is too smart to plagiarize from the New Yorker and this is the work of some overstressed intern or staffer. On the one hand, we might congratulate FZ for not throwing the kid under the bus. On the other hand, he might be figuring he can get away with a few plagiarized paragraphs, but admitting that he puts his own name over the prose of a college sophomore would really croak him.
And then there is RB’s interesting calculus about a celebrity professor or two. I can do the math too and as a one-book-every-five-years kind of writer, am awed by what it suggests. But, RB, do you have anything to go on other than the implausibly high implied production rate? If these folks are publishing the books of their ateliers, it doesn’t seem to me likely that it could be kept secret forever.
8/10/2024 8:35 pm
Zakaria himself defended his repetitious commencement addresses - essentially the same speech at Duke a few weeks before Harvard, and at other universities in previous years - by stating that he did not have anything more to say to the graduates. Now, apparently, he is so busy that he must plagiarize to meet his obligations. I see a pattern of taking shortcuts and expect a thorough examination of his writings to reveal more lapses.
To top it all, in its reporting of the latest Zakaria affair, the NYT uses a photo of him in Harvard regalia at Commencement this year!
8/11/2023 8:34 am
Harry-to answer your question, yes, I do. But like Harry Reid, I can not burn my source(s).
8/11/2023 11:42 am
Very telling that, while TIme has suspended him, Yale has said nothing…it is imperative for Yale’s reputation that he immediately resign or be dismissed from the Board…meanwhile, a few chortles in Cambridge (Lepore is a Harvard Professor of History, tho I haven’t seen that mentioned in the news releases)
8/11/2023 2:28 pm
Back to confess my sins. I just bought the last copy of Imagine in a tiny bookstore. “Can’t order any more,” the clerk told me. I figure I may have a collector’s item and may have helped this bookstore stay afloat.
8/11/2023 2:37 pm
The NYT, after having the article front and center very early this morning on the net, has buried it. Why am I not surprised.
So far, a thirty day suspension from Time for a cheat who, over a period of time, has said very little of substance and has gotten paid very well for saying it. A whole thirty days for plagiarism. Wow. Time really takes it seriously… not.
Why shouldn’t The NYT use the commencement photo. Harvard was very proud of his presence then and had a huge “promotion” about the fact that FZ gave the commencement speech. Perhaps, at commencement, Zakaria was talking to the two HLS professors who did the same thing as he has just done, and received a very mild slap on the wrist by The Dean.
8/12/2023 10:26 pm
Meanwhile, Elizabeth Warren’s plagiarism provokes “no comment” from HLS