Consumers Fight Back
Posted on May 31st, 2012 in Uncategorized | 7 Comments »
So I was in the shaving aisle of the drugstore yesterday, thinking that it would be interesting to write a book about when capitalism doesn’t work. Why? Because two companies, Gillette and Schick, have basically divided up the men’s shaving market, offering largely comparable products at inflated prices—in New York, a single Gillette razor blade now costs about $5. A Gillette blade really lasts less than a week, so you’re talking close to $300 a year on blades alone. Absurd. The blades are so expensive that drug stores now shelve them behind the cash registers, where you can’t even examine the prices; I guess they must be heavily shoplifted items.
And the disposable razors Gillette and Schick make are all pretty crummy (not to mention environmentally unfortunate); I’m convinced they deliberately make lousy ones so that people will choose instead to buy the razors with high-margin replacement blades.
My hunch is that there are no real competitors to these two companies because the barriers to entry are so high; almost everyone buys razors from a handful of chain drug stores in the United States, and it would probably cost tens of millions of dollars to develop a product and get those stores to carry it—if indeed they aren’t pressured or bribed by Gillette and Schick not to, which they probably are.
But perhaps my faith in capitalism has been restored; I was delighted to read in the Wall Street Journal about an Internet-based firm called the Dollar Shave Club, which for a buck a month will send you a razor and four blades. For $6 or $9 a month, a better razor and blades.
I love this idea….and this isn’t a paid endorsement or anything, although I would happily do so if asked…
7 Responses
5/31/2012 1:10 pm
Maybe the biggest scam they ever perpetrated was to make the buying public believe that the blades only last a week — I use my Mach 3’s for months, and they work just fine.
5/31/2012 1:16 pm
Not so the Fusion! It really does lose its edge fast.
5/31/2012 5:28 pm
I’m a member of the D.S. Club and urge you to watch their online video. However, even the Executive blades (which are terrific) can’t quite last me a whole month. Unlike Braun I actually grow real whiskers.
5/31/2012 8:09 pm
Great video, SE.I actually got a 14-pack of Fusion blades at Costco today for $40. A year ago the same pack cost $29.99 or so (I think). I’m between Braun and SE in the whisker dept. so that will last me about a year. Less than a week seems hard to believe, Richard.
6/1/2024 6:44 am
RT, it’s not that you have to toss them after a week, it’s that they degrade so quickly that the shave you get from them after a week is significantly less close than when they’re new. Sure, you can keep on using them, but the shave just isn’t that great. In my opinion, anyway.
Braun…months? That’s gotta hurt.
6/1/2024 8:18 am
Got it, RB. I agree there’s a drop after a week or two, but yes, for me a month or so is tolerable.
6/9/2024 11:59 am
My question is: what does it cost Gellette to make blades, and how much of a markup are they getting?