The Wit and Wisdom of Keith Richards, Cont’d.
Posted on November 22nd, 2010 in Uncategorized | 7 Comments »
My suggestion that Keith Richards’ description of rednecks brought to mind the Tea Party People brought howls of protest below. Inevitable cries of “liberal elitist!” emerged from the commento-sphere, along with the suggestion that the TPPers weren’t at all racist or homophobic or women-hating or any such thing.
Well…maybe they are?
In the Times, Charles Blow writes of the trend within the TPPers to say that blacks like to be discriminated against because it takes them off the hook for failing to advance socioeconomically, and how TPPers say that in fact they are the real victims of racial discrimination.
Blow notes that a poll by the Public Religion Research Institute found that…
…62 percent of whites who identified as Tea Party members, 56 percent of white Republicans, and even 53 percent of white independents said that today discrimination against whites has become as big a problem as discrimination against blacks and other minorities. Only 30 percent of white Democrats agreed with that statement.
Blow points out that there’s absolutely no body of data for that claim, which this blogger finds absurd and pathetic.
We can find racial prejudices in all segments of the population, but pretending that the degree and consequences are comparable is neither true nor helpful. …In fact, some on the right seem to be doing with the race issue what they’ve done with the climate-change issue: denying the basic facts and muddying the waters around them until no one can see clearly enough to have an honest discussion or develop thoughtful solutions.
Of course there are differences, modern elements, particular twists. But we’ve seen this form of populism before. It’s the Know-Nothings, the KKK, the McCarthyites, the hippie-bashers—the paranoid style in American politics. And not to recognize it as such is dangerous.
As Richard Hofstadter once wrote,
We are all sufferers from history, but the paranoid is a double sufferer, since he is afflicted not only by the real world, with the rest of us, but by his fantasies as well.
And, in turn, he afflicts the nation, as we will all find out over the next couple of years.
7 Responses
11/22/2010 2:42 pm
Any relation to Charles Blow?
11/22/2010 3:08 pm
Nope. Not that this necessarily matters, but he’s African-American.
11/22/2010 4:44 pm
Fear is a powerful thing. The antithesis to love. Like every emotion, it is created within each of us, as a reaction to outside events. Unfortunately, humans have a tendency to lay blame elsewhere. It is much easier to fault societal maladies on those groups of people we know the least about. Even if fear is justified it is manifested by each of us. It is a reaction, not an infliction. What if each of us reacted to fear by searching inward for strength instead of lashing outward at others? Just a thought AND much easier said than done.
11/23/2010 8:10 pm
AL, are you suggesting that Richard should take a wander round
Walden Pond?
11/24/2010 7:43 am
Sure, maybe all of us should! And take a dive in as well.
11/29/2010 11:36 pm
Missed that - who commented that TPers weren’t at all racist, homophobic, etc.? I sorta thought the point being made was that lumping them into easy categories smacks of elitism - “inevitable” or otherwise - not that they don’t exhibit various anti-social tendencies. They do, they do - the grouping is full of nuts and bigots and whackjobs and witches and bought-off hacks, but looking at them through a lens provided by Mr. Keith Richards seems kinda superficial. Times were changing in the 60s and there was a lot of discord. After blacks were allowed to sit anywhere they liked, white guys got the idea they ought to be able to grow their hair as long as they liked. The old folks and the rednecks and the stiff necks didn’t like that. Hence old Keef got hassled in diners. We are so beyond that, so deep into a dark wondrous shithole of delusion in this country, that I just can’t take your entire thesis seriously.
11/30/2010 1:38 pm
Thank you, Stargazing.