Sizing Up Summers
Posted on November 26th, 2008 in Uncategorized | 3 Comments »
David Leonhardt in the NYT writes of “the return of Larry Summers.”
Over the last two years, Mr. Summers has carved out a role unlike anyone else’s in theDemocratic Party. He has been something of a shadow economic minister, laying out in real time how a Democratic administration would have responded to the financial crisis. When other economists and policy makers have questions, they often call Mr. Summers.
He is also the centrist who has made it safe for other centrist Democrats to move to the left.
[Blogger: I find this a curious argument—while centrist economists seem to have moved to the left in the past couple of years, I’m not sure you can give Summers credit or blame for that.)
But Mr. Summers also has a habit of alienating some people who could have been his allies. His ill-considered, though also sometimes exaggerated, remarks about women and science are the best-known example. (For more on what he did say, go tonytimes.com/economix.)
If he can avoid such mistakes — and be careful to criticize ideas rather than people — he may find himself ideally suited to the moment.
That seems a fair assessment.
Leonhardt goes on describe Summers’ positions on the issues….but some of the descriptions are, well, a little gentle. Like when Leonhard writes of Summers’ position on regulation:
On this topic, he still sounds like a centrist Democrat. As Treasury secretary starting in 1999, he shepherded a couple of bills that helped deregulate financial markets, and he has made it clear that he doesn’t buy the notion that these laws caused the financial crisis.
As we know, Summers did a little bit more than that: he actively killed a proposal to regulate derivatives, one that likely would have, if not fended off the current crisis, certainly softened it…..
3 Responses
11/27/2008 2:14 am
My daughter tells me I watch too much CNN. Tonight I have decided she is right. All day they have been talking about the terrorist attacks in Mumbai. “Bombs, shooting, hostages, carnage”. Hours of it. Headlines, fires, blood on the floor. It gives one the impression that World War III is upon us. So I spent this evening looking up statistics. I didn’t know, as I’m sure many not so educated people know, that Mumbai has a population of 18,000,000 people. That’s over half the population of Canada. So far 101 are dead, 200 injured. In America, this Thanksgiving weekend, 1400 Americans will be killed on highways. Countless injured. So far, 221,000 civilians and military have been killed in the war on terror world wide…most of them Iraqi civilians. Have we become a world of pansies? We can’t handle this problem of Islamic extremists? I can’t believe that. This needs to be a world wide effort. In the meantime, 30,000 children starved to death today globally. In the war in Viet Nam, you lost 58,000 military people. We won’t even go into Vietnamese civilians or military who died. In World War II, 72,000,000 civilian and military deaths took place world wide. Can we get things into perspective? Is it all ratings? “The most trusted name in news” scaring the hell out of people who are expecting an attack on the United States any minute? We can’t handle this rag tag bunch of thugs and wingnut savages? Pardon me but you have enough troubles….it is not the end of the world and you still have much to be thankful for. Take a day off…drive safely…the stock market has been up for four days in a row…Obama’s audacity of hope is taking shape…there were surely in the last century blacker days than this. And for heaven’s sake, don’t watch CNN. Have the best Thanksiving you can, America.
11/27/2008 10:00 am
Impaulson that was terrific!
11/27/2008 12:03 pm
Thank you…if I may add a couple of things. The body count is now up to 125 and 300 and some injured (I got this from CTV News in Canada). Like a B Grade movie where they can only afford to do one stunt and show it over and over again, on CNN (and for the short shrift CTV gave it), you see the same shot over and over again. The same hotel room in the Taj Hotel has been burning for 2 days now. The same people are running. The same soldiers are shooting. According to CTV, it is now in doubt that this is at all Al Queda related…witnesses report attackers speaking in Hindi. Indications are that this is home grown terrorism and the target, which involves the taking of Canadian, American and British hostages (many of whom have been released) is against the huge western tourism industry in Mumbai.
What was worth reading on CNN are the remarks of Deepak Chopra (whom I don’t always agree with but in this case he is correct.) We’ve got to stop blaming the wrong people (i.e. Iraq). We fight terrorism with terrorism. The Indians and the Pakistanis have to stop blaming each other and help each other. The Saudis sit there and do nothing. The Muslim community, 25% of the world’s population, decries Islamic terrorism and insists that Islam is a peaceful religion but do nothing to discourage Islamic extremists. And on top of it (and I must make clear here that this is my own opinion) they consider themselves hard done by and mistreated…it is politically incorrect to discriminate against Muslims. God forbid Americans should say the wrong thing. Are Muslims aware that during the Second World War, Japanese Americans and Japanese Canadians were forced into internment camps in Canada and America…whole families. They had done nothing. Now there’s a huge outcry against Gitmo. Also during World War II, my father, who came to Canada with his family from Germany when he was 10 years old in 1912 (even before World War I), was required by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police to be fingerprinted after farming peacefully in Canada for 30 years. And I remember Selma and the civil rights marches and the fire hoses and George Wallace. Now we’re going to inaugurate a remarkable African American as President of the United States. And we haven’t gotten anywhere? Maybe a step backward and God knows we have to go green…sorry, people, but I get passionate about this stuff.
Happy Thanksgiving, everybody. I have a happy, healthy grand-daughter here who is waiting for me to read to her about Eeyore and Piglet.