Olympic Fakery
Posted on August 11th, 2008 in Uncategorized | 16 Comments »
In a post below, Standing Eagle chastises me for suggesting that the Elvisian piano player at the Olympics opening ceremony was “key-synching.”
Whichever one of us is right—and just for the record, it’s me—here is something from the opening ceremony that, it turns out, was definitely faked.
Remember watching those incredible fireworks “footprints” that marched across Beijing before winding up at the Bird’s Nest? The ones that I said looked like missile tests?
Fake!
…what [we] were watching was in fact computer graphics, meticulously created over a period of months and inserted into the coverage electronically at exactly the right moment…
…Gao Xiaolong, head of the visual effects team for the ceremony, said it had taken almost a year to create the 55-second sequence. Meticulous efforts were made to ensure the sequence was as unnoticeable as possible: they sought advice from the Beijing meteorological office as to how to recreate the hazy effects of Beijing’s smog at night, and inserted a slight camera shake effect to simulate the idea that it was filmed from a helicopter.
Pretty sneaky! (As this blogger previously noted: the first digital Olympics.)
And here’s an interesting question: Did NBC know, and if so, shouldn’t it have said something? If the network didn’t know, that means the Chinese duped a television network with an elaborate stunt that involved providing them with a fake digital feed so technically impressive that the US couldn’t tell real from fake.
Hmmm…I wonder if all this stuff could be useful in the authoritarian control of hundreds of millions of people….?
(Photo of Fake Fireworks from the Telegraph)
16 Responses
8/11/2024 3:30 pm
The announcers on NBC *did* tell us it was fake. It was unfortunate to have the sound on, but I did have it on, and the lamebrained announcers did tell us it was a computer-generated thing.
So don’t get your knickers too much in a twist.
8/11/2024 3:37 pm
Also, again, this guy is not Elvislike. He’s a world-class musician. When he made his debut in 1999 at the Ravinia Festival (I’m pretending I know what that is — but it’s apparently a big deal) subbing in for the leading classical pianist of the day, Andre Watts, he stunned the cognoscenti. Watts had made a similar debut subbing for Glenn Gould. After the concert, at 1 am, the luminaries goaded him into playing Bach’s Goldberg Variations (Gould’s signature piece) for them. He objected that he didn’t have the score; they said, we know you know it by heart. Sure ’nuff. Blew em away again.
If you know the Goldberg Variations that’s an insane anecdote. It’s the only concrete thing I remember from the article, but Remnick’s point (for Remnick wrote it) is that the guy is legit.
SE
8/11/2024 3:40 pm
I missed that, SE, and if they said it, well, then, mea culpa. But there definitely seems some Internet confusion.
See:
“That was my favorite part of the whole show, and now I find out it was all fake. The NBC commentators did not make it explicitly clear that we were watching CGI footage. What a scam.”
http://2008gamesbeijing.com/beijing-uses-cg-in-the-olympics-opening-ceremony-fireworks/
Regardless, I’m still right about piano man.
8/11/2024 3:48 pm
I never said he couldn’t play; I just said he didn’t.
8/11/2024 4:07 pm
I didn’t see it. But the fact that they informed viewers doesn’t end the discussion, especially since some astute viewers were taken in (no meae culpae needed for that, Richard). What you are seeing is the equivalent of a “photo illustration” like the darkened OJ that was on the cover of a magazine after they arrested him, or the more comic montages that tabloids use on their covers. The fact that the fine print may identify them as such doesn’t end the concerns. A mash-up of photojournalism and graphic synthesis has lots of useful possibilities, and some that are less harmless. Of course pro football viewers are already a bit familiar with this kind of mixture, in the form of the virtual first-down line painted across the field. In this case NBC’s choice seems unfortunate, in light of skepticism that the athletic achievements are completely genuine, given blood doping, steroids, etc. Why advertise to the viewer that some of what they are seeing is unreal? Or on the other hand, why not have twice as many drummers at the next Olympics, half of them synthesized? Same entertainment value for most observers, at half the cost.
8/11/2024 5:39 pm
“Or on the other hand, why not have twice as many drummers at the next Olympics, half of them synthesized? Same entertainment value for most observers, at half the cost.”
This one is easy: it’s because the power of the event is for the people who are actually there. Our awe is vicarious through the attendees.
8/11/2024 5:46 pm
Oh, SE, that’s just BS. “Our awe is vicarious through the attendees”? That is just pretentious silliness.
My awe wasn’t vicarious through the attendees. I couldn’t have cared less about the attendees. Our awe stems from the fact that we believe the remarkable spectacle we are seeing is, in fact, *real.* (Awe, after all, requires belief.)
And as the web conversations about this subject all say eventually, “If *this* was fake, then…..”
8/11/2024 6:01 pm
SE- why are insulting Elvis?!?!
8/11/2024 7:45 pm
For the (so-called) record, Liang Liang is perhaps the most famous classical pianist in the world today, albeit perhaps not the most respected. Critics are certainly divided; but no one says he is not in the very top rank. That said, if he was key syncing, that’s just funny to me. The music was drowned out anyway.
As for the footprints, designed I believe by an artist (Cai Guo Qiang) I happen to be acquainted with, great idea…but yeah, that’s kind of a bummer they were created by CGI (if true), though frankly as a cognoscenti of new technology, I would have thought you’d approve.
Here, by the way, is a discussion of all the planning that went into the fireworks taken from what I think is a Chinese website. It may help elucidate things for y’all:
“The opening ceremony of a total of 57 positions discharge of fireworks, discharge of more than 43,000 various kinds of shell, which in the National Stadium on the discharge of more than 15,000. So intensive discharge of fireworks, the nest of membrane structures can withstand the test, has been a difficult issue.
“The fireworks were responsible for the creative team Cai Guoqiang said that the membrane structure of the nest while the melting point much higher than ordinary plastic, but only 260 degrees Celsius. Once in a fireworks-trial process, the top of the nest have been found multiple Shaochuan of the hole. A barrel or even fired recoilless in the role of pushdown to the film, the film Zale to the nest hole of a medium.
“Ultimately, the opening ceremony of the programme in the discharge of fireworks has gone through six tests, eventually confirmed. The first option and was compared to footprints effects positions decreased by almost half, off-axis launch site is also greatly reduced.”
GOT THAT?
8/11/2024 9:39 pm
I’m actually impressed that the Chinese managed all the fake-out digital effects; impressive compared to the amateurish coverage I’m seeing. Maybe I need HD, because I’m definitely underwhelmed by the NBC coverage. Bob Costas is the worst! Why don’t they have a team, so they can at least banter back and forth?
Beach volleyball is driving me nuts (they play loud music in between each point?!). Not sure why the Aussie women’s basketball team is wearing wrestling or rowing unitards. I want one though! (I won’t even start on the beach volleyball bikinis-when they aren’t anywhere near the water.) And I was pretty appalled by the tabloidish coverage of the dating history of French swimmer Laure Manadou . .
Anyway, loved the “live” blogging. And NPR had an extended interview with Liang Liang tonight . . .
8/12/2023 1:43 am
Bob Costas looks like a robot child, like the one in that Spielberg movie, “AI” or something.
8/12/2023 8:36 am
I call question-begging!
“Our awe stems from the fact that we believe the remarkable spectacle we are seeing is, in fact, *real.* ”
And what does *that* mean if not precisely that someone, somewhere, is watching it happen in person?
Signed,
Stereotypical Literary Scholar
8/12/2023 12:43 pm
More fakery: Olympic Balladeer’s Voice Was Dubbed
8/12/2023 1:43 pm
OMG
8/12/2023 2:03 pm
In light of that evidence I’ll concede provisionally that Richard was right about Liang Liang. I’ll stick to my guns though on the fact that he’s not a lightweight pop star.
When I watch the tape I’ll have a further developed opinion, but I expect it’ll be in accord with Richard’s.
8/14/2008 10:22 pm
Thank you for citing the source of the photograph.