What Drew Faust Should Have Said
Posted on April 29th, 2008 in Uncategorized | 7 Comments »
A few weeks back, Drew Faust endured probably the only controversy (and a small one, at that) of her first year when she was quoted in Business Week as suggesting that smaller private universities and many public ones could not afford to compete with wealthy universities such as Harvard in the realm of scientific research, and should consider cutting efforts in that area while beefing up work in the relatively cheaper humanities.
After a flurry of how-dare-she retorts from presidents of such places, Faust insisted that she had been misquoted by the magazine, and Business Week kinda-sorta issued a retraction.
In fact, Faust’s only mistake, really, was in telling the truth. It’s unfortunate that she didn’t have the courage of her convictions, because she was right. In fact, thanks to funding freezes and budget cuts, the situation for many public universities is even more dire than her assessment.
As the Chronicle of Higher Education reports (subscription only), public universities such as the University of Wisconsin-Madison are so hard up for money, they’re losing both scientists and humanists to Harvard and its peers.
The problem is money. Wisconsin’s stagnating state higher-education budget has forced the university to keep faculty salaries far below average. When professors get feelers from elsewhere, they learn that a move can easily mean a whopping 100-percent salary increase—sometimes more.
The departures have hit the College of Letters and Science hardest.….
What universities are leading the salary charge? Rockefeller University has an average professorial salary of $191, 200. After that is Harvard, with $184, 800…..
7 Responses
4/30/2008 9:21 am
Interesting that Univ. of Madison Wisconsin is mentioned, as their stem cell scientist James Thomson was in the headlines a few months back having made a breakthrough in his field.
4/30/2008 9:48 am
Telling the truth is not necessarily a minor mistake.
4/30/2008 10:44 am
True ’nuff, SE.
4/30/2008 1:08 pm
Yep, sometimes it’s a major one ala Larry Summers. Unpleasant truth should always be tempered with tact, unless you are prepared to deal with the consequences, such as alienation, indignation, outrage, retaliation. I know people who are continually cruel emotionally and hide under the guise of “I’m just telling the truth”. There are ways to tell the truth and ways not to.
4/30/2008 7:42 pm
And some truths are better not said at all.
4/30/2008 7:45 pm
So true.
5/1/2024 11:30 am
A side note perhaps: Wisconsin Madison and stem cell research is an unusual case. They hold patents (through Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation, WARF) in stem cell research that are being contested and that many stem cell researchers elsewhere find excessively restrictive. Patent challengers say that the patents have limited investment in stem cell technologies and that some stem cell research was driven overseas, where WARF patents are not recognized. There are a number of reasons why the issue may no longer be as pressing, but Harvard and other big stem cell institutes have certainly chafed against the WARF patents. Some have painted this dispute as the little guy, Wisconsin, trying to assert its rights in the face of big-money institutions, and in that sense this might be relevant to the discussion.