Historians Do It Better
Posted on February 19th, 2007 in Uncategorized | 12 Comments »
Has anyone else noticed that faculty from the University of Pennsylvania have been more outspoken in their support of Drew Faust than have Harvard professors?
Case in point: Steven Hahn, U-Penn professor of history, writing in the The New Republic about why historians (Drew Faust) make better presidents than economists (one guess).
…as most academics will tell you, economists tend to think that they’re smarter than everybody else, can find the answer to any important question, and don’t need to listen carefully to other opinions. Pity the poor fellow who must present research to an economics department seminar: He can hardly get a word in edgewise.
Historians, nowâthat’s a different matter.
Historians can be as arrogant and tone-deaf as any people who claim intellectual authority, but the nature of their work disposes them to be otherwise. Although historians pose large questions, they are skeptical of easy answers. Although they like to bring order out of apparent chaos, they quickly recognize the complexity of human undertakings. Although they seek to recover something of the past, they soon discover how much digging that requires. They come to learn that historical writing and historical experience involve conflicting perspectives and that they need to confront viewpoints different than their own. Historians have to be prepared to follow unexpected leads and uncharted paths. And they must develop skills (and patience) to hear and understand what their subjects are trying to tell them. It is all a very humbling process.
It’s all a good omen for Harvard, Hahn concludes. And so Larry Summers takes another spear to the chest.
Any economists want to rise to the defense of your profession?
12 Responses
2/19/2007 2:35 pm
No. This guy captures us pretty well: one of the reasons I hung out with the economic historians in graduate school. Too bad I didn’t recognize this back then.
2/19/2007 5:00 pm
Over lunch not long after Summers took over the presidency in 2001, Ellison said, Summers suggested that some funds should be moved from a sociology program to the Kennedy School, home to many economists and political scientists. ”President Summers asked me, didn’t I agree that, in general, economists are smarter than political scientists, and political scientists are smarter than sociologists?” Ellison said. ”To which I laughed nervously and didn’t reply.”
2/19/2007 5:31 pm
It may be an unfair characterization of the Economics Profession to attribute it the characteristics of one of its members.
It is an interesting intellectual question to ask which types of personality are attracted to different disciplines, as well as theoretical and methodological approaches. It is possible that dogmatic and authoritarian personalities are prone to make different choices in this regard than more open minded types.
2/19/2007 11:23 pm
Hey, how come no one is talking about Ruth Wisse and her cleaning lady? I hear she may be hear illegally.
2/19/2007 11:24 pm
Or here.
2/20/2007 12:12 am
Hey, 10:23, why not look at the comments in the two entries after this one, particularly the one entitled “Ruth Wisse and Her Cleaning Lady”.
2/20/2007 12:23 am
Who may be here illegally? Professor Wisse?
2/20/2007 12:33 am
In 2005 a meager 64 students from Brazil enrolled at Harvard.
Perhaps this figure would rise if potential applicants were duly informed of the opportunities that Professors like Ruth Wisse and her colleagues can make available to energetic Brazilians.
2/20/2007 9:17 am
Why don’t we take up a collection and send the poor cleaning lady to English class so she can eventually get a proper job!
Enough with the cleaning lady.
2/20/2007 1:26 pm
If one wants a good example of an excellent university president, who also happens to be an economist, look at Rick Levin at Yale. He’s done an outstanding job.
2/20/2007 4:24 pm
Yeah… I’d mostly agree, except for his campaigning against early admissions programs for years and then failing to jump on the bandwagon when Harvard got rid of theirs. What was up with that?…
2/20/2007 5:56 pm
More importantly, who is Ellison’s cleaning lady, and does she have a degree?