Yale’s Kaavya
Posted on October 24th, 2006 in Uncategorized | 3 Comments »
I’ve refrained from commenting on the pathetic story of Aleksey Vayner till now because, I suppose, it’s just so dispiriting; I want to throw up my hands and say, well, one more con man in the Stephen Glass mode.
But this Times article about Vayner does raise some interesting issues, particularly with regard to whether the Yale undergraduate should be disciplined by the college for setting up what appears to be a fraudulent charity.
A Yale spokeswoman declines to comment, which is unfortunate.
Here’s why: Our nation’s finest universities are supposed to be role models. They hold themselves out as places of virtue, if only because they suggest that their graduates are fit to lead the nation and the world.
So when an undergraduate commits fraud, as Kaavya Viswanathan did at Harvardâwhether legally a crime or notâthis is not just an internal matter for Yale or Harvard. It affects the university’s reputation and the legitimacy of higher education in American society generally.
That’s why it’s important for Harvard to make public statements about Viswanathan or Andrei Shleifer, and why Yale shouldn’t just offer a “no comment” about this student, who is obviously a fraud through and through.
Instead, there’s a “cover your ass” mentality that feels like spin, public relations, and just basically bullshit.
3 Responses
10/24/2006 5:20 pm
The Times article was a bit of a whitewash. The real reporting on this story has been done by the Ivygate blog.
http://www.ivygateblog.com/
10/26/2006 1:55 pm
Agree with you richard…the silence of the admin on the plagiarist event at Harvard has caused embarrassment and disappointment for a lot of undergrads there, including my daughter who is in the same class and some classes as KV.
10/28/2006 10:10 pm
You’re really going to take that personally? That Harvard didn’t burn Kaavya at the stake to protect your daughter’s personal academic credibility? Kaavya hasn’t suffered enough for your taste, your daughter’s credentials not strong enough?