Hillary Flip-Flops on Work
Posted on May 15th, 2006 in Uncategorized | 8 Comments »
Hillary Clinton has apologized for her claim that young people today “think work is a four-letter word.”
Mrs. Clinton explained that she was chastised by her daughter Chelsea, who called her to say, “Mom, I do work hard and my friends work hard.”
(After working hard to get a two-year master’s degree from Oxford, Chelsea works hard pulling down a six-figure salary as a “consultant,” a job which she surely had to work hard to get. At least the Bush girls are doing something useful.)
Mrs. Clinton told Chelsea, “I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to convey the impression that you don’t work hard.”
Which, of course, is exactly the impression that Hillary meant to convey.
Clinton made the original remarks at a speech before the largely-Republican U.S. Chamber of Commerce. She backtracked in a commencement address at Long Island University.
The whole episode reminds one of why it is so hard to like Mrs. Clinton.
The original commentâwhich is actually kind of interesting, and I think not entirely wrongâwas a craven attempt to win over an audience more conservative than she in preparation for a presidential run.
The flip-flop is the inevitable result of saying something that you may or may not mean but which is primarily intended to win the support of an audience which normally wouldn’t support you. It’s hard to stand behind a remark that you probably didn’t believe in the first place.
I still think that the Democrats need a credible alternative to Hillary Clinton… As Newt Gingrich points out, her negatives are awfully high.
8 Responses
5/15/2006 10:19 am
Whether or not she had to work hard to get the job, consultants at McKinsey work pretty long hours for their six figures.
5/15/2006 10:22 am
But what do they do?
5/15/2006 10:59 am
Some working examples:
http://www.mckinsey.com/aboutus/whatwedo/followateam/index.asp
5/15/2006 2:18 pm
Note to the previous poster-the Mckinsey website is quite creepy. Consider the section on “teams” which identifies members of the team by first name only (what’s the point of this quasi-anonymity?) And consider the description of Gordon, which I have appended from their website. So…what does it mean to drive the publication of a book? Does he work for Alloy? Maybe he should try his hand at chick lit. Guess it’s fashionable now for books to be projects that don’t have a real author….
“Outside his client work, Gordon shares his insights on the Chinese business environment and its unique challenges through speeches and workshops to select audiences, through interviews with predominantly local media (e.g. CCTV, China Business, Economic Daily, International Business Daily). He is chief editor of the Chinese edition of the McKinsey Quarterly and has driven the publication of McKinsey-authored books such as Valuation and Collaborating to Compete in the China Market.”
5/16/2006 9:56 am
Is that the Scientology website, or the McKinsey website?
5/17/2006 12:51 pm
If you don’t believe that McKinsey consultants work hard, it’s going to be hard to take anything else you say seriously. What do any management consultants do? Roughly speaking, they try to make businesses run better by, for example, trying to make their business processes work more efficiently. Yes, they speak in consultant gobbledy-gook, which I’ve always felt was annoying and unhelpful, but there are metrics by which to measure their success.
As you may know, they are one of the most coveted employers for Harvard undergrads.
5/17/2006 12:54 pm
Also, young people may take a few more years to get where they are going these days, but they work even harder than their forebears for the most part. It’s obvious in the professions (law, medicine), on Wall St., etc. It’s also clear in the working class if you look at productivity increases for big businesses. People are working longer hours with fewer vacation days.
Yes, the amount of manual labor has declined, but so what? That has nothing to do with young people; it’s just where our economy is headed.
I also fail to see how this particular pander at Clinton really helps with the target audience at the Chamber of Commerce. I haven’t seen them clamoring for a bill in Congress forcing young people to work harder.
5/17/2006 7:17 pm
I know many Harvard students who graduated and became consultants. Some of them were B students, they weren’t interested in academics particularly, but now they break their asses at these firms, working 60-80 hour weeks. It’s okay to just want to make money …