"Be Big"
Posted on May 15th, 2006 in Uncategorized | 6 Comments »
That was Larry Summers’ advice to Harvard undergrads in an event billed as Summers’ “final event” with undergrads (although the baccalaureate and Commencement come to mind).
According to the Crimson, Summers said, âAt a time like this, the question should never be what youâre against. It should be what youâre for, and what each of us individually can do that is really important and that can make a difference and change the world…this University, as it strengthens itself, has the potential to do just that.â
Asked about reports that he had once referred to Harvard College as “Camp Harvard,” Summers responded that he was “substantially misquoted.” He added that he could not remember âprecisely in what context, if at all, I used the phrase âCamp Harvard.”
But he said that if he had used the phrase, it was in reference to high student satisfaction in extracurricular actitivies outside academicsâand his view that a similar level of excitement should be maintained in the classroom.
Translation: I was misquoted, although I don’t remember what I said, but if I did say it this is what I meant.
Of course, the second of those assertions negates the first, and the third does not follow logically from the second.
And the first assertion isn’t true in the first place.
Summers was not substantially misquoted, according to people I interviewed for Harvard Rules. At a first year-meeting with house tutors, he emphasized his desire for students to work harder by saying, “We don’t want this place to be Camp Harvard.”
It is a little difficult to see how that translates into discussing “high student satisfaction with extracurricular activities outside academics.”
Why the Washington-style dissembling? What possible difference could it make now?
How about this for a response: “I was being hyperbolic, but sometimes I do worry that the students’ devotion to extracurriculars comes at the expense of their classroom work.”
In the end, it’s just easier to tell the truth….
6 Responses
5/15/2006 11:09 am
Surprised to see that you haven’t commented on the massive profile the Financial Times did on Summers over the weekend.
5/15/2006 11:58 am
Busy….Mother’s Day, etc.
5/15/2006 12:34 pm
It seemed that the FT reporter had actually interviewed Summers for the profile.
5/17/2006 12:59 pm
The notion of Camp Harvard is total BS. Harvard students are some of, if not the, busiest students in America. Yes, some of that is outside the classroom, but even those activities are mostly of the sort that are commendable (community service, etc.).
They are the overscheduled, overachieving children of the Baby Boomers. What else would we expect? How do you think they get into Harvard in the first place?
5/17/2006 7:24 pm
Camp Harvard does not exist, as you said, although I’m sure a large portion of the student body wishes it were that way. It’s funny, Summers is always telling students that campus social life needs help, and that he supports the Loker Pub and the ridiculous Lamont Cafe, etc. Is he full of it?
It’s hard to approach the issue of to what extent the Harvard student body would rather be getting wasted.
5/17/2006 10:51 pm
Last poster gets it exactly. Summers and his University Hall KGB officer O’Brien have been obsessed by social life stuff, as Harry Lewis has shown. The Lamont cafe is symbolicaly and literally an obscenity: as Harvard is cutting back on library collections it is pouring money into coffee- and pastry-testing surveys.