More Facebook Debate
Posted on August 25th, 2009 in Uncategorized | 3 Comments »
In the Wall Street Journal, Elizabeth Bernstein argues that “Facebook ruins friendships.”
…the problem is much greater than which tools we use to communicate. It’s what we are actually saying that’s really mucking up our relationships. “Oh my God, a college friend just updated her Facebook status to say that her ‘teeth are itching for a flossing!'” shrieked a friend of mine recently. “That’s gross. I don’t want to hear about what’s going on inside her mouth.”
…This brings us to our first dilemma: Amidst all this heightened chatter, we’re not saying much that’s interesting, folks. Rather, we’re breaking a cardinal rule of companionship: Thou Shalt Not Bore Thy Friends.
“It’s called narcissism,” says Matt Brown, a 36-year-old business-development manager for a chain of hair salons and spas in Seattle….
You know that something is going on when a promoter of hair salons and wellness treatments decries narcissism.
Yet it’s silly to blame Facebook for this phenomenon. Yes, it allows for the broader distribution of the banal. But the problem is not boring friends, it’s boring friends, if you take the point. (If not…read off!)
For too many people these days, “conversation” is simply the banal, a hodgepodge of pop culture fodder (“Did you see…?” “How about that…?”) and trivial details of our daily lives. (I’m hardly immune to this; I hoist myself on my own canard.)
Conversation—eloquent, witty, learned, sophisticated, not self-involved but selfless—is a fading art. For the most part, we no longer enjoy it. Instead, we have Twitter. You can say something, but only in 140 characters, and please use the language of Madison Avenue. (It’s a testament to the limits of our imagination that the rhetoric for which we are nostalgic comes from…Madison Avenue.) One doesn’t say something to learn something; one says something to sell something. Most frequently, oneself.
It’s for this reason, I think, that people get so excited about actual eloquence when it almost randomly appears, like some nearly-extinct bird in a birdwatcher’s binoculars. The Moth isn’t a discussion—perhaps it should be—but it does showcase the idea that talking ought to be more than just saying, or typing, or (yes) posting whatever comes to mind.
There’s certainly reason to hope: I think there are numerous Internet examples of clever contributing, if not illuminating conversation. I love the comments section of Gawker, where the commenters are often far cleverer than the posters; unexpected blogs like “Fuck You, Penguin” (“Penguins are sad. You are happy.”); and even Facebook, where quite a few people rise to the occasion and write status updates or posts that are witty, provocative, and sometimes even educational.
The challenge, funnily enough, is the spoken word…..