The 4th of July and Wall-E
Posted on July 3rd, 2008 in Uncategorized |
Ever since I saw Wall-E last week (opening night), I’ve been meaning to write a long post about a) how great it is, and b) the apocalypse as a theme in literature and film of the Bush years. (Think: Cormac McCarthy’s The Road, Jim Crace’s Pesthouse, Kevin Brockmeier’s very fine The Brief History of the Dead.
I’m too tired now to write much about the apocalypse theme, except to say that while every era has its apocalyptic culture, (Fail-Safe, Dr. Strangelove, War Games), I bet that if you could quantify this, the number of people fretting about the apocalypse at the moment is probably higher than any time since the Cuban missile crisis. If George Bush were smart—well, if George Bush were smart, a lot of things would be different—but if he were, he’d pay attention to some of the issues raised in this genre of art (environmental disaster, for one) and realize that these are issues that affect his own approval rating. When the most popular movie in the country features Earth as a planet populated only by a lonely robot and his unkillable cockroach friend, maybe it’s time for the president to realize that people actually do worry about the environment.
I’d like to see an academic trace presidential popularity and its correlation to art of the apocalypse. And I’d like to see a president who, every once in a while, asked academics questions about this sort of thing, and actually listened to the answers.
We have 9/11 to thank for some of this anxiety, but even more, I think, it’s Bush fault. We feel like the world really is going to hell, and Bush is fiddling away (while Dick Cheney lights the matches). Can we survive the rest of the Bush administration? How much more damage can he do on his way out?
Now, back to Wall-e. It is surely the best movie of the year so far, and it’s hard to imagine that there will be a better one in the next few months. It is intelligent, moving, funny, sad, bittersweet, satirical, kind, generous, and, ultimately, optimistic. Its creativity is staggering.
After seeing Wall-E, I left the theater and thought, Yes! Americans can do something right. There remains intelligent life in this country. We do have something to offer the world other than war, debt, and shitty cars.
Sound hyperbolic? See the film. You’ll see what I mean.
I’ll miss the 4th of July this year; I’ll be in the air the entire day, taking off on the 3rd and, thanks to the magic of time zones, landing in Singapore on the 5th.
But on this independence day, I’ll be thankful for the Yankees and the Red Sox, Barack Obama, and Wall-E. Other things as well, of course. But that’s a start.
26 Responses
7/3/2024 10:26 pm
And I’m thankful that the Red Sox just kicked Yankee ass.
7/3/2024 10:52 pm
As am I, Anonymous! Safe traveling Richard, and leave your chewing gum at home.
7/3/2024 11:22 pm
I think the final scene of Terminator 3 (otherwise a disappointing movie) deserves mention here.
But let’s not forget something else. ‘Apocalypse’ means ‘uncovering’ — comes from the same root as ‘calyx.’ So it really is the same concept as Revelation. Which means bleak Mad-Max landscapes are much less in the Western tradition of apocalyptic thought than, say, “The Matrix.” Moreover, that Western tradition extends strongly into the tradition of the Puritan jeremiad, which is why Sacvan Bercovitch so often got to use the word ‘chiliastic.’ See also Michael Wigglesworth’s “Day of Doom.”
All of which is to say that this post, when it’s expanded, should include some considerable mention of the runaway bestseller “Left Behind.”
For more on the jeremiad, see my Crimson op-ed, which comes very close to mentioning Bercovitch by name: http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=513503
For more on Left Behind, see this incredibly muscular and thorough dismantling of the book by an evangelical with sound theology and proper attention to actual Scripture. There’s a ton of it.
http://slacktivist.typepad.com/slacktivist/left_behind/index.html
I taught Left Behind in my Harvard freshman seminar, by the way — along with Dante’s Paradiso. It was good times. The course was called “The Changing Face of Eternity”; its constituent members are rising seniors now.
Jim
7/3/2024 11:23 pm
I think the final scene of Terminator 3 (otherwise a disappointing movie) deserves mention here.
But let’s not forget something else. ‘Apocalypse’ means ‘uncovering’ — comes from the same root as ‘calyx.’ So it really is the same concept as Revelation. Which means bleak Mad-Max landscapes are much less in the Western tradition of apocalyptic thought than, say, “The Matrix.” Moreover, that Western tradition extends strongly into the tradition of the Puritan jeremiad, which is why Sacvan Bercovitch so often got to use the word ‘chiliastic.’ See also Michael Wigglesworth’s “Day of Doom.”
All of which is to say that this post, when it’s expanded, should include some considerable mention of the runaway bestseller “Left Behind.”
For more on the jeremiad, see my Crimson op-ed, which comes very close to mentioning Bercovitch by name: http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=513503
7/3/2024 11:24 pm
Okay, I have no idea what causes a comment to be posted or not. Will wait and see if those pop up.
7/4/2024 12:58 am
Actually, with apologies for pedantry, revelation is a gloss or calque on apocalypse. Same prefix (apo/re) and (Gr.) kalupto / (Lat.) velo both mean put a veil on, which apo/re reverses/
Excellent Crimson article Jim/SE, which I admired back in the day, and do so even more on revisiting.
7/4/2024 8:45 am
Thanks, RT, for the added precision. I said ’same root’ meaning ’same translation,’ which is, of course, not the same thing at all.
Here’s the end of my post, which didn’t get put up:
For more on Left Behind, see this incredibly muscular and thorough dismantling of the book by an evangelical with sound theology and proper attention to actual Scripture. There’s a ton of it.
http://slacktivist.typepad.com/slacktivist/left_behind/index.html
I taught Left Behind in my Harvard freshman seminar, by the way — along with Dante’s Paradiso. It was good times. The course was called “The Changing Face of Eternity”; its constituent members are rising seniors now.
—
Incidentally, here’s my favorite etymology fact (and yes, I AM indeed a big dork): does anyone out there, besides Prof. T., know, without looking it up, where the word ‘helicopter’ comes from?
Happy Fourth of July, by the way. As I said in a morning-prayer talk in late January, 2001, “God bless this nation in its noble principles.” Here’s hoping He gets on the stick with that.
Standing Eagle
7/4/2024 8:46 am
What’s a calque?
7/4/2024 11:46 am
Yes, happy 4th, SE. You can google calque (loan word, e.g. flea market from marché aux puces), but to continue my pendantry since you ask. kalumma ‘veil’ is very old (in Homer e.g.), and apokalupto ‘unveil’ is also pretty old (apokalupsis less so), but Latin revelo (velum = veil) is not in Latin till 1 c. CE, revelatio even later so it was probably loaned from the Greek, and took off with the Vulgate (Latin Bible). Men’s underwear, anyone?
Thanks for the Freshman seminar memories, SE. My Dylan ones went out into the world in June, but I’m repeating this fall and looking forward to it.
7/4/2024 3:24 pm
Loved Wall-E too but actually thought the humankind storyline was ham-fisted…on that, why in the world would we cultivate technology that keeps us morbidly obese? Maybe they have some crazy heart drano in the future, preventing heart disease, etc., but human vanity would never allow for trends to head in that direction…
7/4/2024 10:36 pm
Err… if “the number of people fretting about the apocalypse at the moment is probably higher than any time since the Cuban missile crisis,” isn’t the most likely reason that the number of fundamentalist Christians is higher than it has been over the past half-century, and they believe that the biblical apocalypse is upon us, all evidence that the book of Revelation shouldn’t even be part of the Christian bible notwithstanding?
7/4/2024 11:35 pm
I’m not a fundamentalist Christian and can make no sense of the book of Revelation. Guess I would consider myself more of a common sense Christian if you can be such a thing. I am also normally an optimistic person. However, never in my life…and that includes the Cuban missile crisis because I am old enough to remember it…have I ever felt that the world is more on the verge of going down the economic and environmental toilet than it is right now. If you want to call that the apocalypse you can. I hope I’m wrong.
7/5/2024 8:53 am
Okay, but you probably didn’t really know during the Cuban missile crisis how bad things were.
One is concerned about the environment. But not as concerned as one is about, say, Curtis LeMay having conversations across the table with the Button in the middle.
Pretty damn glad to live in an age when a grotesquely incompetent and immoral president can kill only hundreds of thousands of people, instead of tens of millions (with the caveat of course that we might have missed any meaningful window to ameliorate global warming…).
SE
7/5/2024 11:46 am
What the readers of this blog feel about themselves is probably not relevant to the broad “apocalyptic” cultural phenomenon Richard is describing. .
I’m with SE; things were every bit as scary when the atomic scientists had that clock with the minute hand a few degrees from midnight. What we’ve lost in the transition from Dr. Strangelove to Christian fundamentalism is the sense that our situation is absurd.
7/5/2024 1:24 pm
I was very young during the Cuban missile crisis and at the time I took it very seriously…and with all due respect SE and HL and RT, none of you were there…reading about it isn’t the same as living with that threat. But as I say I was very young then. Now, it amuses me to see Americans still fearful of a nuclear threat from Iran or North Korea…or even Al Queda. Who would be that dumb? Retaliation would be so swift and so horrendous it would be suicidal. I don’t worry about that. I don’t worry about you people and your probably fat paycheques and security. I worry about the poor and the lower middle class and the working stiff who can’t afford to drive to work…but then maybe he isn’t going to have a job to drive to…the people who have to choose between eating and heating their homes. I worry about the seniors on fixed incomes. I worry about the thousands who are losing their homes. I worry about young people struggling with families and the cost of education and the cost of living. I worry about people who have been wiped out by natural disasters. I worry about markets falling and oil soaring. I always had faith in Yankee ingenuity and spirit…you can put a lander on Mars…build and maintain a space station…and with all this technology and brain power and might nobody can come up with an affordable, clean alternative to fossil fuels in a test tube. Or can they…and big oil makes sure that doesn’t happen. I worry about that too. I worry about the world’s infinite capacity for greed.
Tell me it’s going to get better, SE, RT and HL.
7/5/2024 2:40 pm
I share your anxieties, Impaulsen, among any number of other reasons because I have children. Things can only improve some if Obama gets in, not much if McCain does, since he’s dumber than Bush and will end up being run by big oil and the rest.
Iran will be bombed before January, if it is, because of its funding Hezbollah and the like, not because it poses a nuclear threat, and since N. Korea has been removed from the axis of e. I now fear it will happen. Which will make withdrawal from Iraq very difficult and so we can stick around to watch over Exxon Mobil, Shell, Total, BP et al. really moving back in.
I suppose there is some hope that if the economy keeps sliding a more enlightened administration and congress will be forced to look to the interests of the people who nominally elected them and not those of the lobbyists who own many /?most of them. Hey, wasn’t that called the New Deal? Fixing up crumbling bridges and roads, and stuff like that.
I’m no economist so in over my head — as are most of them from the looks of it: apparently a large chunk of the stimulus package went on porn, and doubtless on other things we have trained ourselves to consume and think we need.
Presumably the real optimists out there are precisely the fundamentalists, at least the ones who really believe in the apocalypse, since that’s what they’re looking forward to.
We’ll see, but I really do share precisely those anxieties, Imp.
7/5/2024 4:02 pm
Yeah, I know what you mean…I’m not worrying about the Ed McMahons and others like him who are losing their homes…or the ones who blew their stimulus packages on porn and the like. I worked all my life and raised two decent kids, by myself without child support, earned myself a decent pension, own the best portion of a modest home and now that I am ready to retire, I see my modest retirement dreams go up in smoke in the last and next couple of years. Makes me mad because somebody else’s greed is responsible. I worry about my kids who are trying to make a decent life and they’re struggling so I know where you’re coming from…it’s tough for them and very discouraging. And I can’t imagine why anyone would believe that the good Lord is going to bail us out of a mess we made ourselves…a lot of it with the very best of intentions. I believe we are expected to do a damn sight better than that.
7/6/2024 11:11 am
Why have your modest retirement dreams gone up in smoke
7/6/2024 12:26 pm
In the last couple of years, renovation costs have gone up 50%, home maintenance costs have gone up 50%, the cost of heating my home doubled in this last month, car insurance costs are going up 37%, my house taxes went up 10% this year, and are projected to go up 10% next year yet I couldn’t sell my home because every second house is for sale, air travel is up, we won’t even talk about gasoline, utilities jumped, food costs are soaring, rents doubled in seniors accommodations…I wouldn’t have had a huge disposable income in the first place…modest savings…so that will pretty much use it up. Oh, I will survive and I’ve got considerable equity in my home but I don’t dare use it, but the house is not paid for and interest and mortgage rates will go up so I’ll pretty much be staying home, watching my big screen TV (which is paid for…I’m a heck of a lot better off than a lot of other seniors) and eating a lot of Kraft dinner. And I owe it all to big oil. I’ve done all the greeen things I can and my carbon footprint will be small. And I’ve never had a car accident in my life but I’ve got to pay for the other fools that do. So I’m a little pissed. Anything else you want to know?
7/6/2024 12:33 pm
Yes
Why will the interest rates on your mortgage go up
7/6/2024 12:58 pm
Because I had a good rate in the first place but my mortgage is a 5 year renewable…the rate is already higher than what I had and I have no reason to believe it won’t go higher…everything else has. And even if they don’t …does it really make much difference? But thank you for the best laugh I’ve had all morning.
7/6/2024 6:26 pm
Good luck with it all, Impaulsen. Your anonymous interlocutor was doubtless hoping you would say ‘because I signed a subprime mortgage agreement and didn’t read the fine print’, in response to which he/she could then have told you you had no one else to blame but yourself. Of course he/she would then have been technically correct. But the looser lending standards that led to predators getting commissions for signing such people up are as much at fault as the ignorance of the prey, and that is the sort of thing the next administration needs to attend to.
7/6/2024 8:00 pm
Nope, RT, didn’t do that…wouldn’t do that. Don’t have big credit card debt either. Drive a paid for smaller car that gets excellent gas mileage. I retire in four months…will continue to save…it’s like a debt to myself. I live within my means. Any spare money I have will go to help my daughter and son-in-law (he is working on his Ph.D. in molecular biology…they are having a tough time.) But hey, what are moms for.
There are a few standards that need to be tightened up…I understand that energy costs are going to rise legitimately because of supply and demand…I don’t begrudge the rest of the world a better life but I don’t like the fact that a good deal of the sharp rise in energy costs is artificial…driven by greed.
Thanks for your good wishes…
7/7/2024 4:44 pm
Wall-E? Isn’t that some sort of cartoonlike thing?
7/9/2024 10:14 pm
Very gutsy move by Disney to make this movie, but I must be the only person who was not blown away by it. Perhaps because I was there with my 6 and 4 year old children who found it too dark. It would be nice to have an administration that truly did care about the environment. I’m hoping Obama will show that type of leadership.
Very nice pics by the way from Bali.
7/16/2008 9:45 pm
I just saw this film on your recommendation from this post, Richard. Bawled my eyes out. Great film. I loved it. Thanks.