Shots In The Dark
Monday, August 06, 2024
  Shark Fins and Snow Leopards
The president of Ecuador has reversed his order to deport an American who was involved in a police raid that seized over two tons of shark fins.

The president, Rafael Correa, accused the American of illegally involving himself in Ecuadoran affairs; the American, Sean O'Hearn, a volunteer for Sea Shepherd, pointed out that he has an Ecuadoran wife and child.

In the background of this: a controversy over a new regulation passed by Correa which allows the sale of fins from sharks that are "accidentally" caught, but contains no specifics on how to determine whether a shark is caught accidentally.

Noting that each fin can fetch about $80 in Asia, where they are considered a delicacy, he called the measure a way to help fishermen who "want to bring bread to their children."
"They’re telling us to be sensitive with sharks and insensitive with people," Correa said.

Well, that ought to give the fishermen of Ecuador work for another three or four years, until there are no more sharks left in Ecuadoran waters.

Here's a petition you can sign asking Correa to reinstate the ban on shark fishing, which was in effect before he took office and lifted it.

Meanwhile, police in China seized an illegal cache of rare animal furs.

Police raided a flat in Linxia in the central province of Gansu where they found the remains of bears, snow leopards, clouded leopards and lynxes, Xinhua news agency said.

....Bones of exotic animals are an ingredient of traditional Chinese medicine.

Why is it that it's only the exotic animals which get killed for "medicine"?

My guess: Because the medicine is a crock, and its efficacy, also known as the placebo effect, depends upon the primitive consumer believing in it, something which is more likely to happen if you can say, "contains claw of bear, shark fin, and kidney of snow leopard" than if you say, "It's chicken soup."

The question is, Will Chinese culture modernize sufficiently to address these myths before its growing consumer culture depopulates the world of beautiful and rare animals?

By the way, know why the snow leopard is in demand? Because it's a substitute in that "medicine" for the bones of tigers, which the Chinese have forced into extinction across Asia.
 
Comments:
This post contains yet again a breathtaking combination of ignorance and arrogance. Your "guess" about the placebo effect of Chinese medicine is worth, frankly, a lot of night soil, since it is based on an apparent complete lack of historical knowledge of China, its culture and the numerous contributions made by the Chinese to humankind, including in health/medicine. And your use of the word "primitive" to describe consumers of traditional Chinese medicine is just plain ..... distasteful. You want to know what "primitive" is? Paris Hilton. Fake boobs. Arnold Swarzenegger movies. Cheney and Bush. Outraged environmentalists who've never traveled outside the beltway...other than on a junket.
 
From today's NY Post:

"Celebs will go to great lengths to keep their skin looking young -- Gwyneth Paltrow even uses snake venom to dewrinkle. A spy at Sonya Dakkar spa in Beverly Hills said Paltrow, a frequent customer, walked out with a line of Ultra Lux 9 products -- including a cream that contains the spit of a snake. "It's not Botox," said one insider. "Just a cream that has the venom in it . . ."
 
Outraged environmentalists who've never traveled outside the Beltway?

Huh?

If you could find a single example of this alleged type, I'll give you a hundred bucks. As long as you give me, say, $25 if you can't.

I'll stand by the word "primitive," even—especially—if it applies to Gwyneth Paltrow. Keep your righteous outrage in check long enough to remember that primitive is not necessarily a pejorative. Remember, these are the folks who ate ground-up dinosaur bones in the belief that they were "traditional medicine."

I need no convincing of China's many contributions to humankind. But that's not really what my post was about, is it?

Meanwhile, I'd be more convinced by Anon #1 if he/she actually explained why shark fin, bear claw, and snow leopard bones were such great medicinal contributions.
 
Nice zig zag, as usual.

"Why is it only exotic animals get killed for medicine?" Answer: They don't. Where did you get that idea? (Answer: from a place where the sun doesn't shine.)

"Because the medicine is a crock, and its efficacy, also known as the placebo effect, depends upon the primitive consumer believing in it, something which is more likely to happen if you can say, "contains claw of bear, shark fin, and kidney of snow leopard" than if you say, "It's chicken soup."" Question: Is this statement based on anything -- anything -- at all, other than speculation? Answer: You got it from the same place as above.

Doesn't it occur to you that lacing your environmental arguments with ignorant, offensive cultural stereotyping calls into question the purity of your own motives? Have you ever even been to Asia?
 
Post a Comment



<< Home
Politics, Media, Academia, Pop Culture, and More

Name: Richard Bradley
Location: New York, New York
ARCHIVES
2/1/05 - 3/1/05 / 3/1/05 - 4/1/05 / 4/1/05 - 5/1/05 / 5/1/05 - 6/1/05 / 6/1/05 - 7/1/05 / 7/1/05 - 8/1/05 / 8/1/05 - 9/1/05 / 9/1/05 - 10/1/05 / 10/1/05 - 11/1/05 / 11/1/05 - 12/1/05 / 12/1/05 - 1/1/06 / 1/1/06 - 2/1/06 / 2/1/06 - 3/1/06 / 3/1/06 - 4/1/06 / 4/1/06 - 5/1/06 / 5/1/06 - 6/1/06 / 6/1/06 - 7/1/06 / 7/1/06 - 8/1/06 / 8/1/06 - 9/1/06 / 9/1/06 - 10/1/06 / 10/1/06 - 11/1/06 / 11/1/06 - 12/1/06 / 12/1/06 - 1/1/07 / 1/1/07 - 2/1/07 / 2/1/07 - 3/1/07 / 3/1/07 - 4/1/07 / 4/1/07 - 5/1/07 / 5/1/07 - 6/1/07 / 6/1/07 - 7/1/07 / 7/1/07 - 8/1/07 / 8/1/07 - 9/1/07 /


Powered by Blogger