Send As SMS
Shots In The Dark
Monday, November 20, 2023
  Notes from a Relative Nobody
In general, I try not to highlight posts that rip into me, but since I also try to run this blog fairly, once in a while I'll break with my policy of self-preservation.

For example...

An anonymous poster below writes:

You do realize that your obsession with Larry Summers is really weird, right?

Another thing - man, you have a huge ego. "I could have lived without" you, a relative nobody who didn't even go to Harvard, passing judgment on a man who's infinitely more qualified and accomplished than you ever will be.


A relative nobody who didn't even go to Harvard.
Ouch! That smarts.

It's true that, like the last three presidents of Harvard, I didn't go to Harvard College. I did, however, go to the graduate school, although I left (voluntarily) before finishing my doctorate. But I was there for three years and still have several good friends and lots of warm memories from that time. Though I wasn't an undergrad, I did date one pretty seriously (though not, just so you don't get the wrong idea, one of my students).

As to the matter of obsession, well...no. But thanks for reading the blog enough to think so.

Larry Summers is a very interesting character, and he's hardly been laying low since leaving the presidency. So, since this blog is in large part about Harvard, I cover what he's up to. Summers is also a powerful man, and the record of his use of power is deeply mixed—if you don't believe me, read Joe Stiglitz's book, Globalization and Its Discontents—which is another good reason to pay attention to him. Simple as that.

Do I have a huge ego? Nah. That's one reason I post Monday Morning Zen—to remind myself that we humans are all small and insignificant creatures on this planet, no better and frequently worse than many of our fellow animals. (Also, seals are cute.) It's a good way to start the week.

But because of my professional training, I do read pieces of writing from an editor's point of view. Summers' paragraph on why he cared more about social justice than Friedman did started to turn a warm remembrance into a piece that was more about Summers, and in my most humble opinion, that paragraph should have been trimmed or deleted.
 
Comments:
...or moved up, at least. It was a little too near the end. While I will admit that I'm no fan of the phrase "I could have lived without" (a little too high on the smug meter), Rich is right. This blog began, and continues to be, about Harvard. I'm neither a Larry hater nor an apologist, but I do like that Rich will point out Larry news (they do come from news sources after all, not like he's printing hearsay--which I imagine he could), pieces like this one that I might have otherwise missed. Like a Drudgereport-lite for Harvard. Rich points things out, and we're free to disagree right here in black and white. Seems great to me--keep it up, RB. "Fight in the shade" if you have to.
 
Thanks—I appreciate that.
 
What's wrong with "I could have lived without" in reference to an objection to self-righteous implications from LS about his sense of social justice as he joins his hedge fund? I say to the "Another thing - man, you have a huge ego" poster, why don't you learn how the English language works? I also "didn't even go to Harvard" (as neither did LS). What has that got to do anything? Don't be a wanker!
 
Richard isn't as accomplished. It's true that he's never been the President of Harvard. He's also never been fired as the President of Harvard (and spare me the "resigned" correction). I wager Richard is, however, happier.
 
Richard should receive an honorary degree from Harvard for services rendered to help the institution reflect critically on much that was wrong there. He should be nominated by alumni, faculty and students. But it may take some time for people to value his good work.
 
To the poster who Richard quoted on this blog who had the nerve to criticize him and his choice of words...Man, you have a huge ego. I could have lived without you, a relative nobody passing judgment on a man who's infinitely more qualified and accomplished than you ever will be.

I don't think that's too high on the "smug meter" either.
 
Not to join the chorus of people defending Rich on this one, but what the hell is he suppose to write about on this blog other than things that interest him? He wrote a book on Harvard and Summers so of course it will continue to be a major subject on this blog. Don't read it if it bothers you.
 
Okay, so Richard is extremely intelligent and a great writer. Absolutely, he is. And, agreed that if you don't want to read about Harvard, don't visit the Blog. But....that said - and I have no opinion about LS (could care less about him, actually, I just like reading the Blog sometimes) - Richard does come across, most of the time, as being obsessed w/reporting negatively on Larry Summers. Sometimes it feels a little weird - like there is something personal going on. And that's just my (humble) opinion.
 
Perhaps Richard had the misfortune of dining with Larry at some point and has since found difficulty in being fully objective.
 
Part of what makes Larry so interesting is that he so completely entangled the personal and the professional while president. His personal insults directed against individual professors were proxies for judgments about which fields should grow or shrink, and unwelcome advice from administrators he regarded attempts to undermine his personal stature. So when Richard or anyone else makes what seem to be personal comments about Larry, sometimes a larger point is in the neighborhood. Larry really is a complicated and interesting personality and it is perfectly reasonable to keep looking for clues to explain his pattern of behavior.
 
The logic in the posting of the last blogger is elusive.

Larry Summers gets blamed for many things that were really the decisions and actions of others working for him, including people in Mass Hall, Deans and other administrators.

He has really been a mensch accepting blame for much that happened during his tenure but for which he was not responsible. He has shown much dignity in his silence but even a mensch can run out of patience at some point.

Those for whom it has been so convenient to blame all on the fallen tree should realize that Larry could start talking with great clarity about Harvard any of these days. Who knows, he might even write his own book about the University.
 
He can write his book. So can Robert Clark, Joe Nye, Bill Kirby and Ellen Lagemann, four outstanding intellects and former Deans replaced by Summers' friends and loyalites.
 
An assertion with Larry as subject and "mensch" as predicate, with no negative, is certain to receive nothing but gasps from most of the FAS (outside the Economics Department).

Perhaps some of the evidence on which this would be based is arguable. But it is incontrovertible that Larry lied to the Faculty about his plans for outsourcing Ph.D.-granting rights. Directly lied. Openly lied. Lied with chutzpah. To his own faculty.

This is a mensch? Pfui!
 
It turns out Derek Bok is working for Harvard for free...

http://www.boston.com/news/education/higher/articles/2006/11/22/leader_forgoes_campus_salary/

Bok is deeply aware of the problems with the commercialization of Higher Education. That the Corporation appointed him is indicative that they understand that Harvard is not immune to this problem.

Four more years for Bok! He is an inspiring walking moral lesson to all at Harvard.
 
"He can write his book. So can Robert Clark, Joe Nye, Bill Kirby and Ellen Lagemann, four outstanding intellects and former Deans replaced by Summers' friends and loyalites."

Um: Bill Kirby, Ellen Lagemann -- both initially appointed by Summers.

Robert Clark, Joe Nye -- neither stepped down because of Summers.
 
Post a Comment



<< Home
Politics, Media, Academia, Pop Culture, and More

Name:richard
Location:New York, New York
ARCHIVES
02/01/2024 - 02/28/2005 / 03/01/2024 - 03/31/2005 / 04/01/2024 - 04/30/2005 / 05/01/2024 - 05/31/2005 / 06/01/2024 - 06/30/2005 / 07/01/2024 - 07/31/2005 / 08/01/2024 - 08/31/2005 / 09/01/2024 - 09/30/2005 / 10/01/2024 - 10/31/2005 / 11/01/2024 - 11/30/2005 / 12/01/2024 - 12/31/2005 / 01/01/2024 - 01/31/2006 / 02/01/2024 - 02/28/2006 / 03/01/2024 - 03/31/2006 / 04/01/2024 - 04/30/2006 / 05/01/2024 - 05/31/2006 / 06/01/2024 - 06/30/2006 / 07/01/2024 - 07/31/2006 / 08/01/2024 - 08/31/2006 / 09/01/2024 - 09/30/2006 / 10/01/2024 - 10/31/2006 / 11/01/2024 - 11/30/2006 /


Powered by Blogger