The Gaffe that Won’t Go Away
Posted on January 19th, 2007 in Uncategorized | 7 Comments »
According to the Daily Princetonian, Larry Summers is in hot water again….
The contention revolves around a speech Summers gave this week to the Organization for Surgery, Health, Infection and Treatment, in which he suggested that women may be “intrinsically better” than men at giving birth.
It’s part of the newspaper’s annual joke issue.
I am constantly amazed at how deep the memory of Summers’ women-in-science gaffe runs. Almost invariably, when I tell new acquaintances that I wrote a book about Harvard and its former president, they say something like, “Oh, the one who thinks that women are stupid?”. Or: “The one who thinks that women should stay home?”.
Summers’ remark on women-in-science has over time morphed into a much broader indictment of his views on women generally. It’s now an avatar for general condemnations of sexism. Just listen to Martha Schwartz, the design school prof at Harvard who alleges discrimination in her department.
“The sexism is entrenched,” Schwartz said. “What conclusions can you draw? The Larry Summers one would be that maybe women are not predispositioned to be landscape architects.”
Fairly or not, Summers’ women-in-science moment has become one of the defining episodesâmaybe the defining episodeâof his career.
7 Responses
1/19/2007 10:05 pm
Maybe the only thing the gaffe proves is that some people are intrinsically stupid…
1/19/2007 10:07 pm
nothing wrong with people being stupid, but why do they have to be appointed as Presidents of Harvard?
1/19/2007 10:18 pm
Because the Presidential Selection Committee is not as skilled as Harvard undergraduate admissions office…
1/19/2007 10:23 pm
Who is still left around who remembers that Larry was not admitted to Harvard College?
1/19/2007 10:31 pm
One of the lasting legacies of his gaffe is how the game of telephone can so willfully be perverted.
1/19/2007 10:33 pm
That he was not admitted 35 years ago does not mean he would not be admitted today. It is a different Harvard after all.
1/19/2007 10:35 pm
Yes it is a different Harvard, in large part thanks to Summers… and Hyman of course!