Shots In The Dark
Friday, October 19, 2007
  Does James Watson Have Nobel Syndrome?
Isn't it sort of fascinating how James Watson, who in his book, Avoid Boring People, defends Larry Summers for his women-in-science remarks, now finds himself on a similar hot seat for remarks impugning the intelligence of black people?

And (sort of) just as Summers would lose his job in the extended aftermath of those remarks, so has Watson been suspended from the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory?

Now a clever article in the Telegraph (those Brits! nothing if not clever) suggests that Watson is afflicted with Nobel Syndrome, an ailment that comes to the very intelligent who become so infatuated with their intelligence that they abandon the intellectual rigor which won them the Nobel in the first place.

Nobel Syndrome often emerges after retirement. ...Remove a great mind from this ultra-sceptical environment, then replace it with friends, family and colleagues who are happy to nod and smile when you go old coot, and it is easy to see how a pop star of science ends up talking drivel.

And did you know that winning a Nobel has been found to add two years to your life? I suspect that Watson just gave those two years back....
 
Comments:
What actually is the science that he's talking about in the linked article? Is there any basis at all to a claim that intelligence runs along racial lines? I mean, the guy does have a "pedigree" in this area -- is he actually right? And if it were true, what would we do? Does it make sense to create a picture of the world at odds with the empirical evidence? Is there another way to think of intelligence? Is Africa a mess because of nature, nurture or something else entirely?
 
What a shame for Harvard!
 
Someone should ask Professor Larry Summers what he thinks about the predicament in which Professor James Watson finds himself. Perhaps not enough social intelligence?
 
Richard, I'm surprised you didn't write that the cancellation of Watson's appearance at the London Science Museum was a violation of his first amendment rights and "the height of political correctness". That's what you said about Summer's. I'm glad you didn't say that in this case at least.
 
Science Museum of London canceled a speech Dr. Watson was to have given there today--how does that differ from UCal canceling Larry Summers?
 
There isn't any difference.
 
What does crow taste like, Richard?
 
Harvard Professors have interesting ways to address race. What would Professor Watson think of Professor Fryer's program to pay minority students in NYC who do well on tests?

http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=520144
 
What would Professor Watson think of Professor Fryer's smarts?
 
Post a Comment



<< Home
Politics, Media, Academia, Pop Culture, and More

Name: Richard Bradley
Location: New York, New York
ARCHIVES
2/1/05 - 3/1/05 / 3/1/05 - 4/1/05 / 4/1/05 - 5/1/05 / 5/1/05 - 6/1/05 / 6/1/05 - 7/1/05 / 7/1/05 - 8/1/05 / 8/1/05 - 9/1/05 / 9/1/05 - 10/1/05 / 10/1/05 - 11/1/05 / 11/1/05 - 12/1/05 / 12/1/05 - 1/1/06 / 1/1/06 - 2/1/06 / 2/1/06 - 3/1/06 / 3/1/06 - 4/1/06 / 4/1/06 - 5/1/06 / 5/1/06 - 6/1/06 / 6/1/06 - 7/1/06 / 7/1/06 - 8/1/06 / 8/1/06 - 9/1/06 / 9/1/06 - 10/1/06 / 10/1/06 - 11/1/06 / 11/1/06 - 12/1/06 / 12/1/06 - 1/1/07 / 1/1/07 - 2/1/07 / 2/1/07 - 3/1/07 / 3/1/07 - 4/1/07 / 4/1/07 - 5/1/07 / 5/1/07 - 6/1/07 / 6/1/07 - 7/1/07 / 7/1/07 - 8/1/07 / 8/1/07 - 9/1/07 / 9/1/07 - 10/1/07 / 10/1/07 - 11/1/07 /


Powered by Blogger