# posted by grumpygirl : September 20, 2007 9:46 PM
Obviously you have not been on the receiving end of a proposal. As a woman, I would have loved to have had that moment captured on tape or film. Maybe the men aren't being narcissists, but are looking to capture the moment for their soon to be life partner. In my opinion, most blogs are written by the BIGGEST narcissists on the planet (not an adjective I would use to describe you btw).
# posted by Anonymous : September 20, 2007 9:50 PM
actually, come to think of it, richard, you're a pretty romantic guy yourself. i could actually see you doing something romantic like this.
# posted by grumpygirl : September 20, 2007 10:55 PM
Well, now you tell me which is more romantic: A proposal that is a shared moment between two people, timeless, treasured forever between them; or a proposal in which the authenticity of the moment is changed before it has even happened, because one person knows that a photographer is there, and his actions are invariably affected by the knowledge that there is another person present? The desire to record introduces an element of artifice that is inevitable, that is present whenever anything is recorded for posterity (and those being recorded, or doing the recording, are aware of the act).
Me, I prefer authenticity. Even if it means I'll never have a photo. At least I'll have the memory, and I'll know that it's real--more real than the picture.