To Live and Die with 9/11
In the Boston Globe,
Susan Milligan writes that Rudy Giuliani's addiction to wrapping himself in the shroud of 9/11 seems to be working, at least among Republican voters.
They have put the blunt-speaking former mayor at the top of a crowded GOP field in most polls, and his campaign said Tuesday that he raised more money in the second quarter than any other Republican candidate.Political analysts say Giuliani's pitch is a powerful message to an electorate worried about another assault on US soil, especially after the recent attacks in Britain.
I think this is sloppy analysis. While Giuliani's 9/11 campaign may have given him name recognition that sometimes elevates him over other candidates, what's really going on here is that there's a weak GOP slate of candidates, and virtually all of them have taken a turn at the top of the polls. Giuliani beats Mitt the Mutt Romney and the imploding John McCain. Shocker. But Fred Thompson, a man who has spent more time as a lobbyist than he did as a senator, beats Giuliani in a bunch of polls. So Giuliani's appeal can't be that powerful, can it?
I also question the assumption that the electorate is particularly worried about another terrorist attacked, even after the recent incidents in Britain. Sure, there's always a low-grade anxiety. But I don't think anyone's living in fear, and I certainly don't get the impression that the British attacks had any major psychological impact here......